9 Newbie Water Bath Canning Mistakes to Avoid
*This post contains affiliate links to products we use and love. If you buy something through one of those links, I’ll receive a small commission at no extra cost to you. See our full disclaimer to learn more.
If you’re new to preserving your own food at home, water bath canning is the perfect place to start. You don’t need expensive equipment to get started. As long as you’ve got some proper canning jars with lids and bands, a jar lifter and funnel for handling, and a stock pot big enough for a batch of jars, you’re good to go.
Water bath canning is pretty straightforward, overall. The chances of accidentally producing unsafe food are extremely low as long as you follow tested canning recipes and methods. So, if you have anxiety about foodborne illnesses like me, don’t be intimidated!
That said, there are a handful of common rookie mistakes to be aware of so your projects go smoothly and turn out beautifully. I learned the hard way with some of these when I first went whole hog into canning lots of things (instead of just jelly).
Most of these mishaps cause minorly frustrating problems like failed seals, siphoning, or the occasional broken jar. A few create the risk for spoilage or even botulism, a serious food-borne illness. When you know how to avoid these from the start, you can confidently turn out canned goods you know are gift-worthy and safe to eat.
Short on time? Pin this for later:
Mistake #1: Changing Ingredients or Using Untested Recipes
I’m a self-proclaimed kitchen witch, meaning I like to take creative liberties when cooking. I often cook without a recipe and experiment with different ingredients and different ways of doing things. When it comes to canning, though, following your heart instead of a tested recipe is the biggest way to unknowingly create a safety risk.
Water bath canning relies on two factors to safely preserve food: heat and acidity. The heat from the boiling water bath takes care of garden-variety mold spores and bacteria that cause spoilage. However, the temperatures reached during boiling aren’t hot enough to kill botulism spores. It’s the acidity that prevents botulism spores from multiplying in water bath canned food, since they cannot grow below a certain pH.
Official canning recipes, such as those in the Ball Blue Book (or ballmasonjars.com) and the NCFHP website, have been tested in a lab setting by experts to make sure the finished product falls within a safe acidity range every time. If you change the main ingredients, you may unknowingly change the acidity and create an environment where botulism can grow.
Botulism poisoning is incredibly rare (with the amount of “rebel canning” going on in the wild, folks would be dropping like flies if it wasn’t). It’s not something to be paranoid about as a new canner. However, it is a serious illness when it happens. So, IMO, it’s not something to mess around with when we have proven ways to avoid the risk. Getting lightning struck is also very rare, but most of us wouldn’t go stand in the middle of a field during a thunderstorm.
Safely Customizing Water Bath Canning Recipes
Fortunately, you don’t have to entirely run your kitchen like a government-funded lab when canning. While base ingredients and acidifiers should be kept as is, you can safely customize the flavors in most canning recipes to suit your taste.
Here are some tips for safely editing tested canning recipes:
-Adjust seasonings as desired: Ingredients such as salt, sugar, spices, and herbs are for flavor only and can be safely tweaked or changed to your liking.
-Make minor ingredient swaps in equal ratios: For example, if you want to increase the heat in a recipe that calls for ½ cup of chopped jalapeños, you can sub for ½ cup habaneros or serrano peppers instead. Just don’t change the type of produce (i.e., don’t sub peppers for corn).
-Adjust batch size: You can safely double (or half) most canning recipe as long as you keep the ingredient ratios the same. Note: don’t do this with jelly or jam, as doubling the liquid in the cook pot may cause it not to set properly.
-Never reduce acidifiers: Recipes involving low-acid or borderline foods (like peppers and tomatoes) always call for ingredients like lemon juice or vinegar to keep the acidity in the safe zone. Reducing those acidifiers will make the food unsafe for water bath canning.
-Get creative with pickled vegetables: Since the vinegar-heavy brine is what creates high acidity in brined pickle recipes, you have more leeway with your choice of ingredients. It’s perfectly safe to take a basic dill pickle recipe and jazz it up with hot peppers, garlic cloves, sliced onions, or whatever you like as long as you keep the brine (vinegar to water) ratio the same.

Mistake #2: Filling Cold Jars with Hot Food
It’s not a myth: pouring boiling hot food into a cold canning jar can absolutely cause the bottom of the jar to blow out. This happens when the sudden temperature change causes rapid expansion that “shocks” the glass. And, unfortunately, modern canning jars seem more prone to this than the older ones were.
To avoid thermal shock breaks, you need to pre-heat the canning jars before filling them with hot food. Arrange the clean, empty jars in the canner, cover with water, and allow them to come to a simmer on the stove while you prep your recipe ingredients. Then, turn the heat down to low so they stay steaming hot but not boiling as you’re filling.
Once you’re ready to start filling, you’ll want to keep the jars warm throughout the process. The best way to do this is to work one jar at a time. Remove a single empty jar, fill it, add the lid and band, and place it back in the canner. Keep working this way until all those jars are filled and loaded.
Tip: According to current guidelines, you do NOT need to boil your empty canning jars before filling as long as you’ll be processing your recipe in the boiling water bath for at least ten minutes. Washing them well is all that’s needed.

Mistake #3: Not Removing Air Bubbles
Unless you’re canning something that’s completely liquid when filling, like fruit juice or jelly, you’ll have air bubbles or pockets you can’t see after filling each jar. Those bubbles will rise to the surface during canning. When you pull your jars out after processing, you’ll find the liquid levels or contents have shrunk down by an inch or more.
While not a safety issue, jars of canned food that are only ¾ full clearly aren’t ideal. You want to make good use of all the space you have. To prevent shrinkage due to air pockets, use a silicone de-bubbler like the kind that comes with every good canning tool set. After filling each jar, run the de-bubbler along the inside of the jar to release trapped bubbles. Then, top of the contents as needed.
If you don’t have a dedicated de-bubbler, you can use whatever you have on hand. Popsicle sticks, wooden skewers, and even a butter knife will work fine.
Tip: If your jar’s contents are packed too tightly to get the de-bubbler in (which is often the case with pickled veggies), you can gently tap the bottom of the jar on the counter to release the bubbles.
Mistake #4: Not Leaving Proper Headspace
Headspace refers to the amount of room you need to leave at the top of the jar when filling. During the water bath process, the food inside the jars expands due to the heat. If there’s not enough room for this expansion, the jar’s contents will force its way past the lid. This causes siphoning (jars that come out less than full) and failed seals.
As a general rule, jams and jellies need ¼ inch headspace, while pickled veggies, preserved fruits, tomato products, and salsas require ½ inch. Good canning recipes always specify required headspace.
Complete canning tool sets like this one include a measuring tool that makes measuring correct headspace really easy for newer canners. Once you’ve been canning for a little bit, you’ll be able to gauge headspace just by eyeballing it.

Mistake #5: Not Wiping Jar Rims After Filling
Food residue on the rims of canning jars are a common cause of failed seals. Even when you’re using a funnel, it’s quite possible to unknowingly spill or drip something on the rim as you’re filling. I always make it a habit to thoroughly wipe each jar rim with a clean, damp cloth before placing the lid and band.
Mistake #6: Over-Tightening Bands
During the canning process, air should be able to vent from your jars as the contents heats and expands. If it can’t, trapped air may warp or buckle the canning lid, leading to failed seals. This is why it’s essential not to over-tighten your bands.
The age-old advice for this is to apply the bands “finger-tip tight.” This is confusing to me, because my version of “finger-tip tight” is probably different from my husband’s “finger-tip tight.” What it really means: don’t crank down on the band once it’s in place. Twist until it’s just snug, and don’t force it to go on tighter.

Mistake #7: Not Using a Canning Rack
The purpose of a canning rack is to provide a little space between the jars and the bottom of the canner. Jars directly touching the base of the canner may break due to overheating or rattling against the metal during processing.
If you don’t have a canning rack, you can just use a clean towel or washcloth to line the bottom of the canner. This creates enough of a buffer to prevent overheating or vibrating.
Mistake #8: Not Adjusting Processing Time for Altitude
Oddly enough, water boils at different temperatures depending on elevation above sea level. At sea level, the boiling point is 212 Fahrenheit. At my elevation, approximately 1,600 feet above sea level, the boiling point is around 209 F. Since water boils at a lower temp where I live, I need to add extra processing time when water bath canning to make sure spoilage organisms are completely eliminated.
Plan to adjust your processing time if your elevation is more than 1,000 feet above sea level. At 1,600 feet, I need to add five minutes of processing time for any water bath canning recipe I make. Those above 3,000 feet will need to add even more time, depending on your exact elevation. You can reference Ball’s altitude adjustment chart to easily determine how much processing time you need to add for higher elevation canning.
Mistake #9: Leaving Bands On for Storage
For starters, leaving the bands on your jars when you stick them in the pantry can reduce the lifespan of your canned goods. The bands restrict airflow around the edges of the lid, creating a prime environment for rust. While a little rust forming on the lid in storage isn’t a problem, heavy rusting can cause pinhole air leaks and, ultimately, a failed seal and spoiled food.
Secondly, those canning bands aren’t finished with their job and ready to retire to the cabinet once you’ve canned a single batch of something. While lids should only be used once, you can reuse bands again and again as long as they don’t have a lot of rust. I’ve been using the same bands for years by washing them after each canning project and storing them in an airtight container to keep out moisture and prevent rusting.

This might seem like an unnervingly long list of things that can go wrong. Really, though, most of them are just little learning experiences when they happen. Once you’ve attempted a water bath canning recipe or two, you’ll be much more confident with your process.

